Neutrino Atlas · Worksheet · Lesson 3.6
Dirac or Majorana?
Read the lesson on neutrino-atlas.com and answer the questions. Tick exactly one answer each time.
https://neutrino-atlas.com/learn/dirac-or-majorana/
Part A – Beginner
What makes it possible that the neutrino is its own antiparticle?
- A Its very high speed
- B It has no electric charge
- C It spins in both directions
- D It is heavier than the electron
What is a Majorana neutrino?
- A A neutrino with electric charge
- B A fourth neutrino flavour
- C A neutrino that never changes
- D A neutrino identical to its antiparticle
What signature do detectors look for in neutrinoless double beta decay?
- A A sharp peak at one total electron energy
- B Two neutrinos flying out together
- C A flash of visible light
- D A broad spread of electron energies
According to the best experiments, how long would half of the atoms at least need to decay without neutrinos?
- A About ten years
- B About the age of the universe
- C More than 10²⁶ years
- D About a thousand years
Part B – Intermediate
How large is the wrong-helicity admixture for an eV-scale neutrino at MeV energies?
- A About one in ten
- B About one in a thousand
- C About one in a million
- D Exactly zero
In the type-I see-saw, mD ≈ 100 GeV and M ≈ 10¹⁴–10¹⁵ GeV give which light neutrino mass?
- A About 0.01–0.1 eV
- B About 1–10 eV
- C About 100 GeV
- D About 1 keV
Which experiment holds the strongest half-life limit described in the lesson?
- A GERDA with germanium
- B CUORE with tellurium
- C EXO-200 with liquid xenon
- D KamLAND-Zen with xenon
Why did GERDA Phase I disfavour the Heidelberg–Moscow claim?
- A It used a different isotope
- B It saw 3 events where about 6 signal events were expected
- C It observed a much larger peak
- D It found the decay in xenon instead
Part C – Expert (optional)
Which neutrino mass does the dimension-five Weinberg operator (LH)(LH)/Λ produce?
- A mν = mD · M
- B mν = y Λ / v²
- C mν = v / Λ
- D mν = y v² / Λ
For light Majorana neutrino exchange, how does the inverse 0νββ half-life depend on mββ?
- A Linearly in mββ
- B As (mββ / me)²
- C As (mββ / me)⁴
- D It is independent of mββ
What does the Schechter–Valle theorem state?
- A Majorana phases enter oscillation probabilities
- B Dirac masses need Yukawa couplings of order one
- C Any ΔL = 2 process implies a Majorana mass
- D 0νββ requires the normal ordering
In which regime does the half-life sensitivity grow linearly with exposure M t?
- A Background-free
- B Background-limited
- C Resolution-limited
- D Phase-space-limited
Extra task
In three or four sentences, explain to someone without a physics background what this lesson is about.
Answer key for teachers
- B – Electron and positron are told apart by their charge. The neutrino has none, so the most obvious difference between particle and antiparticle is missing.
- D – In 1937 Ettore Majorana showed that for a chargeless particle the equations allow particle and antiparticle to be identical; in Dirac's picture they always differ.
- A – No neutrinos carry energy away, so the two electrons always share exactly the same total energy, producing a tiny, sharp peak.
- C – GERDA, KamLAND-Zen and CUORE have seen no signal, so the half-life must exceed 10²⁶ years, millions of billions of times the age of the universe.
- C – The admixture is of order m/E. An eV mass at MeV energies gives about 10⁻⁶, which makes direct tests of the Majorana nature hopeless.
- A – From mν ≈ mD²/M, the very heavy Majorana mass M pushes the light neutrino mass down to the 0.01–0.1 eV range.
- D – With about 745 kg of enriched xenon dissolved in liquid scintillator, KamLAND-Zen reached 3.8 × 10²⁶ years, above GERDA's 1.8 × 10²⁶ years.
- B – Using the same isotope, germanium-76, GERDA expected about six signal events if the claim were correct but saw only three in total, consistent with background.
- D – The mass is suppressed by the high scale Λ; with Λ ≈ 10¹⁴–10¹⁵ GeV and y of order one it reproduces the observed neutrino mass scale.
- B – The rate factorises as G⁰ᵛ gA⁴ |M⁰ᵛ|² (mββ / me)², so nuclear matrix element uncertainties translate directly into the spread of mββ limits.
- C – Whatever mechanism drives 0νββ, a ΔL = 2 process generates a Majorana mass at loop level, although that induced mass can be negligibly small.
- A – Without background the sensitivity scales as M t; in the background-limited regime it grows only with the square root of M t / (B ΔE).