Comparisons
Comparisons: neutrino physics side by side
20 often-confused concepts, experiments and methods – each with a short answer, a comparison table and an explanation.
- Dirac neutrinovs.Majorana neutrinoA Dirac neutrino is distinct from its antiparticle and conserves lepton number. A Majorana neutrino is its own antiparticle, so lepton number can change by two units. Which description is correct is still unknown; observing neutrinoless double beta decay would establish the Majorana case.
- Neutrinovs.AntineutrinoAntineutrinos are the antiparticles of neutrinos. They carry opposite lepton number, are observed with opposite helicity and arise in different reactions: β⁻ decay emits antineutrinos, while β⁺ decay and solar fusion emit neutrinos. Whether the two are truly distinct particles is still unknown.
- Normal orderingvs.Inverted orderingIn normal ordering the mass state ν3 is the heaviest; in inverted ordering it is the lightest, below the closely spaced pair ν1 and ν2. Which ordering nature uses is not yet known. JUNO, DUNE, Hyper-Kamiokande and KM3NeT/ORCA aim to settle it.
- Neutrinovs.PhotonA photon is a massless spin-1 boson that carries the electromagnetic force and interacts readily with charged matter. A neutrino is a spin-½ fermion with a tiny mass that interacts only through the weak force and gravity, so it passes through almost anything.
- Neutrinovs.ElectronBoth are spin-½ leptons, and the electron neutrino is the electron’s weak-interaction partner. The electron carries charge −1 and a mass of 0.511 MeV; the neutrino is neutral, over a million times lighter and interacts only weakly, which makes it far harder to detect.
- IceCubevs.KM3NeTBoth detect Cherenkov light from neutrino interactions in about a cubic kilometre of transparent medium. IceCube uses Antarctic ice and has been complete since 2010; KM3NeT uses Mediterranean sea water, is still under construction and sees the southern sky through the Earth.
- Super-Kamiokandevs.Hyper-KamiokandeHyper-Kamiokande is the successor to Super-Kamiokande: the same water Cherenkov technique, but about 260,000 tonnes of water instead of 50,000 and more sensitive photomultipliers. Super-K has been running since 1996; Hyper-K is planned to start operation around 2028.
- JUNOvs.DUNEBoth aim to determine the neutrino mass ordering, by opposite routes. JUNO measures fine oscillation ripples of reactor antineutrinos over 52.5 km, almost unaffected by matter; DUNE sends a GeV neutrino beam 1,300 km through the Earth, where matter effects reveal the ordering.
- Water Cherenkov detectorvs.Liquid scintillator detectorWater Cherenkov detectors record the faint, directional light cone of fast charged particles and scale cheaply to huge masses. Liquid scintillators emit far more light, but in all directions, giving sub-MeV thresholds and better energy resolution at the cost of direction and size.
- Solar neutrinosvs.Atmospheric neutrinosSolar neutrinos come from nuclear fusion in the Sun's core: pure electron neutrinos below about 20 MeV. Atmospheric neutrinos come from cosmic rays striking the air: mainly muon-flavour neutrinos at GeV energies and above. They probe different oscillation parameters.
- Reactor neutrinosvs.Accelerator neutrinosReactors emit pure electron antineutrinos of a few MeV in all directions, as a free by-product. Accelerators make focused, pulsed beams of GeV muon neutrinos or antineutrinos. Reactor experiments measure disappearance; beams also reveal flavour appearance, CP violation and matter effects.
- KATRINvs.CosmologyKATRIN weighs the neutrino in the laboratory from the tritium beta spectrum and limits mβ to below 0.45 eV, almost without model assumptions. Cosmology infers the mass sum Σmν from cosmic structure; DESI DR2 with CMB gives below 0.0642 eV, but only within ΛCDM.
- Water Cherenkov detectorvs.Liquid-argon TPCA water Cherenkov detector records rings of light from fast charged particles and scales cheaply to hundreds of kilotonnes. A liquid-argon TPC images ionisation tracks in three dimensions with millimetre detail, separating electrons from photons and seeing slow protons, at higher cost per tonne.
- Neutrinovs.NeutronBeyond zero charge and spin ½, they share little. The neutron is a composite baryon of about 940 MeV that lives roughly 15 minutes when free; the neutrino is a stable elementary lepton below 0.45 eV, felt only through the weak force and gravity.
- Active neutrinosvs.Sterile neutrinosActive neutrinos, νe, νμ and ντ, take part in the weak interaction and have been observed since 1956. Sterile neutrinos are hypothetical states without weak charge, visible only through mixing and gravity. Their number and masses are unknown, and no search has confirmed one.
- Two-neutrino double beta decayvs.Neutrinoless double beta decayIn two-neutrino double beta decay a nucleus emits two electrons and two antineutrinos; this rare process has been observed. Neutrinoless double beta decay emits only the two electrons. It would violate lepton number and prove that neutrinos are Majorana particles, but has never been seen.
- Charged currentvs.Neutral currentIn a charged-current interaction a neutrino exchanges a W boson and turns into its charged partner lepton, revealing its flavour. In a neutral-current interaction it exchanges a Z boson and remains a neutrino, so all three flavours look the same.
- Vacuum oscillationsvs.Matter effects (MSW)Vacuum oscillations arise because the three mass states travel with slightly different phases. In matter, electron neutrinos also scatter on electrons, which shifts their energy. This MSW effect changes mixing and oscillation length and, unlike vacuum oscillation, reveals the sign of Δm².
- T2Kvs.NOvABoth send off-axis muon-neutrino beams to distant detectors to measure νe appearance, δCP and the mass ordering. T2K uses 295 km and Super-Kamiokande; NOvA uses 810 km and a scintillator detector, with stronger matter effects. Their first joint analysis appeared in Nature in October 2025.
- Cosmic neutrino backgroundvs.Cosmic microwave backgroundBoth are relics of the hot early universe. The neutrino background decoupled about one second after the Big Bang and should now be at about 1.95 K, unobserved directly. The microwave background was released about 380,000 years later and is measured at 2.725 K.