KATRINvs.Cosmology
KATRIN vs. cosmology: two ways to weigh the neutrino
In short
KATRIN weighs the neutrino in the laboratory from the tritium beta spectrum and limits mβ to below 0.45 eV, almost without model assumptions. Cosmology infers the mass sum Σmν from cosmic structure; DESI DR2 with CMB gives below 0.0642 eV, but only within ΛCDM.
| Criterion | KATRIN | Cosmology |
|---|---|---|
| Quantity measured | mβ, an effective electron-neutrino mass | Σmν, the sum of the three masses |
| Physical effect | Shape of the tritium spectrum near 18.6 keV | Neutrinos slowing the growth of cosmic structure |
| Current limit | mβ < 0.45 eV (90 % CL, 2025) | Σmν < 0.0642 eV (95 %, DESI DR2 + CMB) |
| Translated to the other quantity | Allows Σmν up to about 1.35 eV | Implies mβ of roughly 0.01 eV (normal ordering) |
| Model dependence | Minimal; relies on energy conservation | High; assumes ΛCDM and standard neutrinos |
| Main uncertainties | Spectrometer response, source effects, background | Cosmological model and combination of data sets |
| In evolving dark energy | Unchanged | Loosens to Σmν < 0.163 eV |
| Status | 1,000 days of data completed in Oct 2025 | Already close to the oscillation minimum of 0.059 eV |
Two different quantities
KATRIN in Karlsruhe measures the electrons from tritium beta decay. A non-zero neutrino mass removes a tiny slice of energy from them and distorts the spectrum just below the endpoint. Because the electron neutrino is a mixture of three mass states, KATRIN sees the effective electron-neutrino mass mβ, an average of the three masses weighted by their electron-flavour shares. Cosmology sees something else. Relic neutrinos from the Big Bang are so numerous that their total mass slows the clumping of matter on small scales, so galaxy surveys and the cosmic microwave background constrain the sum of the neutrino masses, Σmν. When the three masses are nearly equal, Σmν ≈ 3 mβ, so the KATRIN limit corresponds to about 1.35 eV for the sum.
Robust versus sensitive
KATRIN's 2025 limit, mβ < 0.45 eV at 90 % confidence, rests on kinematics alone: energy conservation and the well-understood physics of tritium decay. It holds whatever the universe is made of and whether neutrinos are Dirac or Majorana particles. The cosmological bound is about twenty times tighter. DESI DR2 combined with CMB data gives Σmν < 0.0642 eV at 95 % confidence, but this assumes the standard ΛCDM model with a cosmological constant. If dark energy is allowed to evolve, as some DESI fits suggest, the same data give Σmν < 0.163 eV. Cosmological limits are therefore powerful but conditional.
Where the two approaches meet
Oscillation experiments require Σmν of at least about 0.059 eV for normal ordering. The ΛCDM bound sits just above that value, and some analyses even prefer formally negative masses. This tension could point to systematic effects, new cosmological physics or unexpected neutrino properties. Laboratory experiments cannot reach this region soon. KATRIN completed 1,000 days of data taking in October 2025 and is analysing them for its final result, while Project 8 is developing a technique aimed at tens of meV. Should a laboratory experiment ever find mβ well above the cosmological expectation, standard cosmology would need revision; should cosmology detect a mass first, direct measurements remain the model-independent cross-check.
Read on
- Lesson: How heavy is a neutrino? →
- Lesson: Neutrinos in cosmology →
- FAQ: How is the neutrino mass measured? →
- FAQ: How much does a neutrino weigh? →
Related terms
- KATRIN
- Cosmological neutrino mass bounds
- Neutrino mass in cosmology
- Effective Electron-neutrino mass
- Sum of neutrino masses
- Cosmological neutrino-mass tension
Last updated: · Editorial standard
Cite this page
Text
Neutrino Atlas (2026). “KATRIN vs. cosmology: two ways to weigh the neutrino”. Retrieved 22 November 2026, from https://neutrino-atlas.com/comparisons/katrin-vs-cosmology/BibTeX
@misc{neutrinoatlas2026arisonskatrinvscosmology,
title = {KATRIN vs. cosmology: two ways to weigh the neutrino},
author = {{Neutrino Atlas}},
year = {2026},
url = {https://neutrino-atlas.com/comparisons/katrin-vs-cosmology/},
note = {Accessed 2026-11-22},
language = {english}
}