Neutrino Atlas · Worksheet · Lesson 3.2
The solar neutrino problem
Read the lesson on neutrino-atlas.com and answer the questions. Tick exactly one answer each time.
https://neutrino-atlas.com/learn/the-solar-neutrino-problem/
Part A – Beginner
Why are solar neutrinos the only direct way to check the Sun's centre right now?
- A They come straight from the core, unlike light
- B They are slower than light
- C They are made at the Sun's surface
- D The corona reflects them
What share of the predicted neutrinos did Davis find at Homestake?
- A About twice the prediction
- B Exactly the prediction
- C About a third
- D About one in a thousand
Why could SNO count solar neutrinos of every flavour?
- A It used much more gallium
- B It counted argon atoms one by one
- C It lay deeper than Homestake
- D Neutrinos of any flavour can split heavy-water deuterium
What is the MSW effect?
- A A cooling of the solar core
- B Flavour change enhanced by interactions with solar electrons
- C Absorption of neutrinos in the Earth
- D A counting error in chlorine detectors
Part B – Intermediate
What threshold does the ³⁷Cl reaction have, and which neutrinos does it mainly see?
- A 0.233 MeV; pp neutrinos
- B 0.814 MeV; mostly ⁸B and ⁷Be
- C About 7 MeV; only ⁸B
- D 1.8 MeV; reactor antineutrinos
Why were the gallium experiments the cleanest test of the solar model?
- A They measured each event's direction
- B They saw all three flavours
- C They had the largest target mass
- D Their 0.233 MeV threshold reached luminosity-fixed pp neutrinos
Why did the differing deficits point to the neutrinos themselves?
- A No core-temperature change could produce that energy dependence
- B The detectors shared a calibration error
- C The Sun's luminosity varied
- D Gallium absorbed the chlorine signal
What did SNO find in 2002 for the ⁸B flux (in 10⁶ cm⁻² s⁻¹)?
- A Total 1.76, electron neutrinos 5.09
- B Both about 5.09
- C Total 5.09, electron neutrinos 1.76
- D Total 65,000, electron neutrinos 1.76
Part C – Expert (optional)
Why was an apparently stronger suppression of ⁷Be than ⁸B a hint of new physics?
- A ⁷Be neutrinos were seen only by water detectors
- B ⁸B does not depend on core temperature
- C ⁸B is produced from ⁷Be, so this is astrophysically impossible
- D ⁷Be neutrinos cannot oscillate
What does SNO's ratio φCC/φNC ≈ 0.34 measure?
- A The high-energy ⁸B survival probability
- B The pp flux
- C The day–night regeneration
- D The mixing angle θ₁₃
What are Pee in the matter-dominated and the vacuum-dominated regimes?
- A About 0.57 at high E, about 0.31 at low E
- B sin²θ₁₂ ≈ 0.31 at high E, about 0.57 below 1 MeV
- C About 1 in both regimes
- D About 0.5 in both regimes
In the two-flavour MSW formula with A = 2√2 GF ne E, where does resonance occur?
- A At A = 0
- B At A = Δm² sin 2θ
- C At A = 2√2 GF
- D At A = Δm² cos 2θ
Extra task
In three or four sentences, explain to someone without a physics background what this lesson is about.
Answer key for teachers
- A – Light from the surface left the core long ago, while neutrinos fly straight out and reach the Earth eight minutes later.
- C – Davis counted argon atoms made from chlorine in a 615-tonne tank; the deficit appeared in 1968 and persisted until 1994.
- D – In 2002 SNO found the total matched the solar model, while only about one third arrived as electron neutrinos.
- B – Passing through the dense solar interior, neutrinos interact gently with electrons, which can strongly enhance their change of flavour.
- B – Homestake's final 1970–1994 average was 2.56 ± 0.23 SNU, compared with model predictions of about 8 SNU.
- D – The pp flux is fixed almost directly by the solar luminosity. SAGE and GALLEX/GNO found about 65–70 SNU against roughly 130 SNU predicted.
- A – Chlorine saw about one third, water and gallium about one half. A cooler core cannot reproduce this pattern across energies.
- C – The neutral current counted all flavours and matched the solar model; the remaining two thirds arrived as νμ or ντ, a 5.3σ result.
- C – Free-flux fits before SNO gave this pattern; no change to the solar model can suppress the parent ⁷Be more than its product ⁸B.
- A – CC sees only νe while NC sees all flavours, so the ratio gives Pee for ⁸B, consistent with adiabatic MSW and Pee ≈ sin²θ₁₂.
- B – Above a few MeV neutrinos leave the core as nearly pure ν₂ adiabatically; below about 1 MeV vacuum averaging gives 1 − ½ sin²2θ₁₂.
- D – There the term (cos 2θ − A/Δm²) vanishes, so sin²2θm reaches its maximum of 1 regardless of how small the vacuum angle is.