IllustrationV. A. Lyubimov
Lyubimov led the ITEP group that in 1980 reported a non-zero electron antineutrino mass of about 30 eV from the beta spectrum of tritium bound in valine, a value large enough to close the universe. The claim triggered a generation of tritium experiments (Los Alamos, Mainz, Troitsk) that refuted it and set limits of about 2 eV.
- Nationality
- Soviet
- Field
- Experimental nuclear physics
- Institutions
- Institute for Theoretical and Experimental Physics (ITEP), Moscow
Background
V. A. Lyubimov is known as the leader of an experimental nuclear physics group at the Institute for Theoretical and Experimental Physics (ITEP) in Moscow. Little biographical information about him is available in English, but his group's tritium experiment is one of the most consequential episodes in the history of neutrino mass measurements: it produced a famous wrong result that set off a generation of better experiments.
The ITEP tritium experiment
Tritium decays by beta decay to helium-3, releasing only 18.6 keV. If the electron antineutrino has a mass, the electron spectrum ends slightly below this endpoint and its shape is distorted in the last few tens of eV. Measuring that distortion is the most direct, model-independent way to determine the effective electron-neutrino mass. The ITEP group, with Lyubimov, E. G. Novikov, V. Z. Nozik, E. F. Tretyakov and V. S. Kosik, used an iron-free toroidal magnetic spectrometer of the type developed by Tretyakov. As source they used tritium chemically bound in the amino acid valine, evaporated as a thin layer onto aluminium.
In 1980, after five years of data, they reported a non-zero mass of between 14 and 46 eV at 99% confidence. Improved runs left the value essentially unchanged; the final result, published in 1987, was about 30 eV. Such a mass would have made relic neutrinos a large part of the matter in the universe, as hot dark matter, enough to close it gravitationally. The claim therefore attracted intense attention from cosmologists as well as particle physicists.
Refutation and legacy
Other groups set out to check the result with different sources and spectrometers. Experiments in Zurich and at the Institute for Nuclear Study in Tokyo found upper limits of about 10 eV, and a Los Alamos group including Hamish Robertson used gaseous molecular tritium, whose atomic and molecular final states can be calculated reliably, to exclude the ITEP value in 1991. The error is generally attributed to the complex valine molecule, whose final-state excitations and energy losses were not well enough understood. The next generation, the MAC-E filter experiments at Mainz and Troitsk led by Ernst Otten, Christian Weinheimer and Vladimir Lobashev, pushed the limit to about 2 eV, and KATRIN has since reached below 0.5 eV. The ITEP claim thus helped create the modern tritium endpoint programme.
Known for
- 1980 claim of a ~30 eV electron antineutrino mass from tritium beta decay
Chronology
- 1980Reports ~30 eV neutrino mass
- 1991Los Alamos gaseous T2 experiment contradicts the claim
Original papers
- V. A. Lyubimov, E. G. Novikov, V. Z. Nozik, E. F. Tretyakov, V. S. Kosik, An estimate of the νe mass from the β-spectrum of tritium in the valine molecule, Phys. Lett. B 94, 266 (1980)DOI 10.1016/0370-2693(80)90873-4
Experiments
- ITEP tritium experiment
Connected people
Frequently asked questions
Was the ITEP neutrino mass of 30 eV correct?
No. Experiments in Los Alamos, Zurich, Tokyo, Mainz and Troitsk excluded it; today's limit from KATRIN is below 0.5 eV.
Why was the claim so important?
A 30 eV neutrino would have dominated the mass of the universe as hot dark matter, so the result had major implications for cosmology.
Mentioned in 8 pages
Last updated: · Editorial standard
Cite this page
Text
Neutrino Atlas (2026). “V. A. Lyubimov”. Retrieved 22 November 2026, from https://neutrino-atlas.com/people/valentin-lyubimov/BibTeX
@misc{neutrinoatlas2026peoplevalentinlyubimov,
title = {V. A. Lyubimov},
author = {{Neutrino Atlas}},
year = {2026},
url = {https://neutrino-atlas.com/people/valentin-lyubimov/},
note = {Accessed 2026-11-22},
language = {english}
}