Holmium-163 experiments (ECHo, HOLMES)
Calorimetric experiments that infer the electron-neutrino mass from the electron-capture spectrum of ¹⁶³Ho.
¹⁶³Ho is implanted in metallic magnetic calorimeters (ECHo) or transition-edge sensors (HOLMES), so all de-excitation energy except the neutrino's is measured. The spectrum's endpoint near 2.8 keV is sensitive to mν. This approach is complementary to tritium, with different systematic errors.
In plain words
Holmium-163 is a rare radioactive isotope that decays by capturing one of its own inner electrons. All of the released energy, except the share carried off by the neutrino, ends up as a tiny burst of heat inside the material. If you embed the holmium in an extremely cold, extremely sensitive thermometer, you can measure that heat for every single decay. The missing energy at the very top of the resulting spectrum reveals the mass of the neutrino – this time the neutrino itself, not the antineutrino studied with tritium.
In detail
In electron capture, ¹⁶³Ho + e⁻ → ¹⁶³Dy* + νe, the dysprosium atom is left with a vacancy in an inner shell and relaxes by emitting X-rays and Auger electrons. A calorimeter that fully contains the source records the sum of these energies. The spectrum consists of broad resonance lines for capture from different shells, and the neutrino mass distorts its upper end, near the Q-value of about 2.86 keV – one of the lowest of any known electron-capture decay.
The approach was suggested by Álvaro De Rújula and Maurizio Lusignoli in 1982. Its systematic uncertainties differ completely from those of tritium experiments: there is no external spectrometer and no molecular final-state problem, but pile-up of two decays within the detector response time and the atomic physics of the spectrum must be understood precisely.
The experiments
- ECHo (Electron Capture in ¹⁶³Ho), led from Heidelberg, uses metallic magnetic calorimeters operated at about 20 mK. ¹⁶³Ho is produced by neutron irradiation of enriched erbium-162 in a reactor, chemically separated and ion-implanted into the absorbers.
- HOLMES, led from Milan, uses transition-edge sensors read out with microwave multiplexing.
Key results
- HOLMES (2025, Physical Review Letters): mν < 27 eV, 90% credible interval.
- ECHo-1k (2026, Physical Review Letters): mν < 15 eV, 90% credible interval, together with a calorimetric Q-value of 2862 ± 4 eV that agrees with independent Penning-trap mass measurements.
Why it matters for neutrino physics
These limits are still far above KATRIN's, but they come from a completely independent method and test the electron neutrino rather than the antineutrino, a direct check of CPT symmetry in this sector. Reaching sub-eV sensitivity requires around 10¹⁴ recorded decays, which means scaling to many thousands of detector pixels. Both rely on cryogenic calorimetry.
Frequently asked questions
Why is holmium-163 used instead of tritium?
It has a very low decay energy, its decay can be measured fully inside a cryogenic detector, and it probes the neutrino rather than the antineutrino, with systematic errors independent of tritium experiments.
What is the best holmium limit on the neutrino mass?
ECHo-1k reported mν < 15 eV (90% credible interval) in 2026.
Original papers
- ProposalA. De Rújula and M. Lusignoli, Calorimetric measurements of 163holmium decay as tools to determine the electron neutrino mass, Phys. Lett. B 118, 429 (1982)
- ProposalL. Gastaldo et al., The electron capture in 163Ho experiment – ECHo, Eur. Phys. J. Spec. Top. 226, 1623 (2017)DOI 10.1140/epjst/e2017-70071-y
Related terms
Mentioned in 9 pages
Last updated: · Editorial standard
Cite this page
Text
Neutrino Atlas (2026). “Holmium-163 experiments (ECHo, HOLMES)”. Retrieved 22 November 2026, from https://neutrino-atlas.com/terms/holmium-163/BibTeX
@misc{neutrinoatlas2026termsholmium163,
title = {Holmium-163 experiments (ECHo, HOLMES)},
author = {{Neutrino Atlas}},
year = {2026},
url = {https://neutrino-atlas.com/terms/holmium-163/},
note = {Accessed 2026-11-22},
language = {english}
}