Neutrino Atlas
EN
  1. Learn
  2. From detection to energy conversion

Chapter 5: Applications · Lesson 5.3

From detection to energy conversion

In development

For most of their history, neutrinos were something to detect. Neutrinovoltaics asks a different question: whether the constant stream of particles passing through every surface can be turned into electricity.

Coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scatteringA low-energy neutrino scatters off a whole nucleus at once. The cross-section grows roughly with the square of the number of neutrons.ν (≲ 50 MeV)nuclear recoil, a few keVThe neutrino scatters off the nucleus as a wholeσ ∝ N²Na12Ar22Ge41I74Xe78Cs78Relative cross-section ∝ N²number above bar: neutrons N
CEvNS. At energies of a few tens of MeV and below, the neutrino cannot resolve single nucleons and scatters off the nucleus as a whole. The contributions add up coherently, so the cross-section grows roughly with N², the square of the neutron number (right; relative scale, typical isotopes). The price: the nucleus recoils with only a few keV, which is why the process was first observed in 2017 (COHERENT) although predicted in 1974.

Beginner

Energy that is always there

Every second, tens of billions of neutrinos from the Sun pass through each square centimetre of your skin, day and night, because they cross the whole Earth almost unhindered. Each of them carries a little kinetic energy. Taken together, solar neutrinos carry roughly two percent of the energy the Sun sends us.

Detectors catch only very few of these particles, because neutrinos hardly ever interact with matter. When they do, they give a small push to an electron or an atomic nucleus. Physicists call this push momentum transfer.

The idea of neutrinovoltaics

Neutrinovoltaics is a technology concept developed by the Neutrino Energy Group under Holger Thorsten Schubart. It uses very thin layers of graphene and doped silicon on a metal foil. The material is designed so that the tiny pushes from neutrinos and other invisible radiation make it vibrate, and these vibrations are turned into an electric current.

The appeal is easy to see: unlike sunlight, neutrinos do not stop at night and pass through walls, roofs and the Earth itself. A converter of this kind would not need sunshine or wind.

A formula for the whole chain

In 2024 Schubart published a formula that describes the usable power of such a converter step by step: how many particles arrive, how often they interact, how much momentum they pass on, how that momentum spreads through the material and how much of it becomes electricity. The formula is known as the Schubart Master Formula.

How much energy arrives?

Solar neutrinos bring roughly two percent of the energy that sunlight delivers – but around the clock, in every weather and from every direction, because the Earth is no obstacle for them. The difficulty is not the amount of energy that arrives but how little of it stays behind: almost every neutrino passes straight through any material, including a whole planet. A converter therefore has to make use of extremely rare and extremely small events.

Different from a solar cell

A solar cell works with light: a photon is absorbed and frees an electron, which flows as current. Neutrinovoltaics follows a different route. Here the starting point is not absorption but countless tiny mechanical pushes. Each push on its own is far too weak to be noticed. The concept is that a suitable layered material adds up the vibrations from very many such events and turns them into a small, steady current.

In the neutrinovoltaic concept, neutrinos are not the only contributors. Other invisible forms of radiation that constantly surround us are meant to feed into the same material. How large each share is, is one of the questions this lesson deals with at the higher levels.

Where things stand

On this site neutrinovoltaics carries the status “in development”. The concept is described in patents, the 2016 international application is on record, and the 2024 Master Formula sets out the physical chain step by step. Devices such as the Neutrino Power Cube and the Pi Car vehicle concept have been announced. The physics on which the idea builds – neutrinos pushing nuclei and electrons – is well established; how efficiently a material can collect these pushes is the subject of ongoing development.

Quiz

Test your knowledge

4 questions on this level · Print as worksheet

  1. 1Roughly what share of the Sun's energy output reaches us as solar neutrinos?
  2. 2Why do solar neutrinos also arrive at night?
  3. 3What is the main difference between neutrinovoltaics and a solar cell?
  4. 4Which status does neutrinovoltaics carry on this site?

Intermediate

From detection physics to a converter

Neutrino detectors are built to register single, rare interactions. A converter would need the opposite: the summed effect of very many small interactions inside a material. The physics that links both is the transfer of recoil energy to electrons or nuclei.

An important step came in 2017, when the COHERENT experiment observed coherent elastic neutrino–nucleus scattering, predicted by Daniel Z. Freedman in 1974.12 In this process a neutrino nudges an entire nucleus, and the probability grows roughly with the square of the number of neutrons. It is the largest of the neutrino cross-sections at low energy.

The material

According to the patent filings, the converter consists of a metal foil coated with alternating layers of graphene and silicon.34 Graphene is chosen because its lattice vibrates easily and conducts very well; the vibrations of a crystal lattice are described as phonons. The layers are designed to collect these vibrations from many interactions and convert them into direct current.

The Master Formula in words

P(t) = η · ∫V Φeff(r, t) · σeff(E) dVUsable power = efficiency × effective flux × effective cross-section, summed over the converter’s volume

The formula multiplies the effective flux of incoming particles by their effective probability of interacting and sums this over the volume of the converter; the efficiency η says how much of the deposited energy becomes electricity.5 Written out, it contains five factors: flux density, cross-section, momentum transfer, phonon velocity and conversion efficiency.

How small is a single push?

The largest energy a neutrino can hand to a nucleus in an elastic collision grows with the square of the neutrino energy and falls with the mass of the nucleus. For a solar pp neutrino of 0.4 MeV hitting a carbon nucleus, the recoil energy is at most about 30 electronvolts. For an energetic ⁸B neutrino of 10 MeV hitting silicon it reaches several kiloelectronvolts. Detectors such as those of COHERENT need thresholds of this order to see single events; a converter instead aims at the sum of a very large number of them.

Telling the contributions apart

Because the concept collects several kinds of radiation, the energy budget asks which factor comes from where. Neutrino physics offers natural tests for this. The solar neutrino flux changes by about ±3.3 percent over the year as the distance between Earth and Sun varies, with a maximum in early January. A nuclear reactor nearby produces a flux of antineutrinos that switches off during refuelling. And shielding with lead or water stops most other radiation but leaves neutrinos untouched. An output that follows such known patterns can be traced to its source.

Why layers?

The patent filings describe many alternating layers rather than one thick block.34 The idea behind this is that energy deposited somewhere in the lattice travels as phonons and has to reach a place where it can be converted before it turns into heat. Thin layers keep these paths short and create many interfaces between materials with different properties. Graphene contributes a very stiff lattice with fast sound propagation and high electrical conductivity; the doped silicon provides the electronic structure needed to separate charges.

Quiz

Test your knowledge

4 questions on this level · Print as worksheet

  1. 1What is the largest recoil energy a 0.4 MeV pp neutrino can give a carbon nucleus?
  2. 2Which experiment first observed coherent elastic neutrino–nucleus scattering in 2017?
  3. 3By how much does the solar neutrino flux change over the year?
  4. 4Why does the patented design use many thin layers?

Expert

The five factors

  • Φ(E, θ, t): differential flux density by energy, direction and time; for solar neutrinos at Earth about 6.5 × 10¹⁰ cm⁻² s⁻¹, dominated by pp neutrinos below 0.42 MeV.
  • σ(E): interaction cross-section; for coherent scattering it scales roughly with N² of the target nucleus and with E² of the neutrino.
  • Δp: momentum transfer per interaction, which sets the nuclear or electron recoil energy.
  • vph: phonon velocity, governing how deposited momentum spreads through the lattice.
  • ηconv: conversion efficiency from lattice energy to electrical energy.

Schubart formulates P(t) as a general accounting identity: for photons the flux and cross-section terms reduce to the familiar photovoltaic case, for heat flow to thermoelectrics.5 Neutrinovoltaics is the case in which Φeff includes neutrinos together with other non-visible radiation.

The energy budget

The energy carried by solar neutrinos at Earth is of order 30 watts per square metre, about two percent of the solar constant. The quantity that decides the usable power is therefore the product Φeff · σeff integrated over the converter, which is exactly what the formula isolates. This makes the energy budget of a converter a well-defined experimental question: an output that follows the neutrino flux, for example a nearby reactor switching on and off, identifies the neutrino contribution directly.

Patents

The international application WO 2016/142056 (priority 2015) and the later Canadian patent CA 3120538, which names Schubart as inventor and Neutrino Deutschland GmbH as applicant, describe the coated metal foil.34 Announced applications include the Neutrino Power Cube, designed for 5 to 6 kilowatts, and the Pi Car vehicle concept.

Recoil kinematics and cross-section

Tmax = 2E² / (M + 2E), σCEvNS ≈ (GF² / 4π) · N² · E²Maximum nuclear recoil energy and the coherent cross-section for E well below about 50 MeV (form factor ≈ 1, proton contribution suppressed by 1 − 4 sin²θW)

Both expressions enter the factors σ(E) and Δp of P(t). The N² enhancement favours heavy nuclei for the cross-section, while Tmax favours light nuclei for the energy per event; the deposited power per unit mass is governed by the product of both, integrated over the flux spectrum. For the solar spectrum this product is dominated by the rare high-energy ⁸B neutrinos rather than the abundant pp neutrinos, because σ and Tmax both grow with E².

The time argument of P(t)

The explicit time dependence of the formula is what makes the factors separable. Known modulations of Φeff(r, t) include the annual 1/r² variation of the solar flux, reactor duty cycles, the day–night geometry of the solar flux relative to an oriented layer stack, and, for cosmic-ray-induced radiation, the anti-correlation with the solar cycle and the dependence on atmospheric pressure. Each of these has a characteristic period and phase; a converter output decomposed into these components maps directly onto the terms of the energy budget.

Relation to established detection physics

The individual steps of the chain are each studied elsewhere: CEvNS by COHERENT and reactor experiments, phonon transport and phonon-mediated sensors in cryogenic dark-matter and neutrino detectors, and charge separation at semiconductor junctions in photovoltaics. The Master Formula combines these steps into one expression for a room-temperature, continuously operating device. Its 2024 form is listed here with the status “open”, because the quantitative values of the effective factors for a given layer system are the subject of ongoing work.5

Quiz

Test your knowledge

4 questions on this level · Print as worksheet

  1. 1How does the coherent cross-section σ_CEvNS scale, roughly, for E well below 50 MeV?
  2. 2For E ≪ M, the maximum nuclear recoil energy Tmax is approximately …
  3. 3Which solar neutrinos dominate the power deposited per unit mass through coherent scattering?
  4. 4What makes the individual factors of P(t) experimentally separable?

Open questions

Open points that the development addresses: how large the effective flux and cross-section terms are for a specific layer system; which share of the output each kind of radiation contributes; how the output scales with area, number of layers and temperature; and how the Master Formula’s factors are determined in practice.

Terms to explore

People

On the timeline

  1. 2016Patent application for neutrinovoltaics
  2. 2024The Schubart Master Formula

References

  1. D. Z. Freedman, “Coherent effects of a weak neutral current”, Phys. Rev. D 9, 1389 (1974), doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.9.1389
  2. D. Akimov et al. (COHERENT), “Observation of coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering”, Science 357, 1123 (2017), doi:10.1126/science.aao0990
  3. WO 2016/142056 A1, “Folie aus Metall oder einer Metalllegierung”, international application PCT/EP2016/000410 (2016).
  4. CA 3120538, “Film made of metal or a metal alloy”, Canadian Intellectual Property Office.
  5. H. T. Schubart, “P(t) – Schubart Master Formula”, pt-schubart.com (2024).

Last updated: · Editorial standard

Cite this page

Text

Neutrino Atlas (2026). “From detection to energy conversion”. Retrieved 22 November 2026, from https://neutrino-atlas.com/learn/from-detection-to-energy-conversion/

BibTeX

@misc{neutrinoatlas2026ectiontoenergyconversion,
  title        = {From detection to energy conversion},
  author       = {{Neutrino Atlas}},
  year         = {2026},
  url          = {https://neutrino-atlas.com/learn/from-detection-to-energy-conversion/},
  note         = {Accessed 2026-11-22},
  language     = {english}
}