Neutrino Atlas
EN
  1. History of the neutrino
  2. The hypothesis
  3. 1955

1955Experiment

Davis shows antineutrinos do not make argon

Confirmed

Raymond Davis placed chlorine-based detectors near reactors at Brookhaven and later Savannah River to look for argon-37 production by reactor antineutrinos. He found none, at a level well below what would be expected if neutrinos and antineutrinos were identical in this reaction. The null result supported the idea that neutrinos and antineutrinos are distinct, now described by lepton number conservation. It also established the radiochemical technique Davis later used at Homestake.

Portrait of Raymond Davis Jr.
Raymond Davis Jr., whose chlorine experiment at a reactor found no signal in 1955, showing that antineutrinos differ from neutrinos.Image: U.S. Department of Energy from United States · Public domain · commons.wikimedia.org
Date
1955
Kind of event
Experiment
People involved
Raymond Davis Jr.

The situation before

Bruno Pontecorvo had proposed in 1946 that neutrinos could be detected through their capture on chlorine-37, which produces radioactive argon-37. Nuclear reactors were the strongest available sources. But reactors emit antineutrinos, from the beta decay of neutron-rich fission fragments, while the chlorine reaction is the inverse of electron capture and should be induced by neutrinos. Whether that difference mattered was an open question. If neutrino and antineutrino were the same particle, as Ettore Majorana's theory allowed, reactor antineutrinos should produce argon too.

What happened

Raymond Davis, a chemist at Brookhaven National Laboratory, set out to try. In 1954 he placed tanks of carbon tetrachloride, a cheap chlorine-rich cleaning fluid, next to the Brookhaven research reactor and shielded them. After exposure he flushed the liquid with helium to sweep out any argon atoms, collected them and counted their decays in a small proportional counter. He found no argon attributable to the reactor.

ν̄ₑ + ³⁷Cl → ³⁷Ar + e⁻ (not observed)The reaction Davis searched for at reactors. Its absence showed that antineutrinos do not behave like neutrinos in this capture.

He published the null result as "Attempt to detect the antineutrinos from a nuclear reactor by the ³⁷Cl(ν̄, e⁻)³⁷Ar reaction" in the Physical Review in 1955. A larger set-up at the Savannah River reactor, where Clyde Cowan and Frederick Reines were working at the same time, pushed the limit on the cross-section for this reaction to below about 10⁻⁴⁵ cm², far below what identical particles would have given.

Reaction

The result was read as evidence that neutrinos and antineutrinos are distinct. It fitted a new conservation law: in 1953 Emil Konopinski and Hormoz Mahmoud had proposed assigning a lepton number of +1 to electrons and neutrinos and −1 to their antiparticles, which forbids an antineutrino from producing an electron. After the discovery of parity violation in 1957 it became clear that the interpretation is subtler: because the reactor antineutrinos have the wrong handedness, the reaction would be suppressed even if they were Majorana particles. The question of the neutrino's nature thus remained open.

A rumour in 1957 that Davis had seen a few events prompted Pontecorvo to consider neutrino-antineutrino transitions, the first idea of neutrino oscillations. The events did not survive further analysis.

Why it matters

The reactor runs established the chlorine-argon technique, its backgrounds and its sensitivity. Davis then turned to the Sun, whose fusion reactions emit neutrinos, not antineutrinos. That path led to the Homestake mine and the first measurement of solar neutrinos.

Frequently asked questions

What did Davis find at the reactor?

No argon-37 production. Reactor antineutrinos do not induce the capture reaction that neutrinos would.

Did this prove neutrinos are not Majorana particles?

No. After 1957 it was understood that the antineutrinos' handedness alone would suppress the reaction. Whether neutrinos are Majorana particles is still unknown.

Original papers

  1. MeasurementR. Davis, Attempt to Detect the Antineutrinos from a Nuclear Reactor by the Cl37(ν̄,e−)A37 Reaction, Phys. Rev. 97, 766 (1955)DOI 10.1103/PhysRev.97.766

Concepts

Last updated: · Editorial standard

Cite this page

Text

Neutrino Atlas (2026). “1955: Davis shows antineutrinos do not make argon”. Retrieved 22 November 2026, from https://neutrino-atlas.com/timeline/1955-davis-reactor-null/

BibTeX

@misc{neutrinoatlas2026line1955davisreactornull,
  title        = {1955: Davis shows antineutrinos do not make argon},
  author       = {{Neutrino Atlas}},
  year         = {2026},
  url          = {https://neutrino-atlas.com/timeline/1955-davis-reactor-null/},
  note         = {Accessed 2026-11-22},
  language     = {english}
}

Back to the timeline