Solar neutrino problem
The decades-long puzzle that fewer solar neutrinos were detected than predicted.
From 1968 Davis' chlorine experiment saw about one third of the predicted rate; later experiments confirmed deficits. SNO (2001-2002) solved it by showing the total active flux matched the solar model while νe were depleted - flavour conversion via the MSW effect (large mixing angle solution).
In plain words
For three decades physicists counted neutrinos from the Sun and always found too few, between a third and two thirds of what theory predicted. Either the model of the Sun was wrong, or the experiments were, or something happened to the neutrinos on their way to Earth. The answer turned out to be the third: electron neutrinos change into other flavours, which the early detectors could not see.
History
- 1968: Raymond Davis Jr. reports the first results of the chlorine experiment at Homestake. Over its lifetime it measured about 2.6 SNU, roughly a third of the rate predicted by John Bahcall's solar model.
- 1969: Vladimir Gribov and Bruno Pontecorvo suggest that neutrino oscillation could explain the deficit.
- 1978 to 1986: Lincoln Wolfenstein, Stanislav Mikheyev and Alexei Smirnov show that matter in the Sun can enhance flavour conversion, the MSW effect.
- 1985: Herbert H. Chen proposes a heavy-water detector able to count all flavours, which becomes SNO.
- 1989: Kamiokande confirms a deficit in real time, at about half the predicted boron-8 rate, and shows the neutrinos come from the Sun.
- 1990s: the gallium experiments SAGE and GALLEX measure about 70 SNU against about 130 predicted, including the low-energy pp neutrinos.
The solution
In 2001 SNO measured electron neutrinos through the charged-current reaction on deuterium and compared them with Super-Kamiokande's elastic-scattering rate, which is also sensitive to muon and tau neutrinos. The difference showed that other flavours were arriving. In 2002 SNO's neutral-current measurement counted all flavours directly: the total matched the solar model, while only about a third were electron neutrinos. In the same year KamLAND observed reactor antineutrino disappearance with the same parameters, selecting the large mixing angle solution.
Why it matters for neutrino physics
The solution proved that neutrinos change flavour and therefore have mass, which the original Standard Model did not allow. Davis and Masatoshi Koshiba shared the 2002 Nobel Prize in Physics, and Arthur B. McDonald shared the 2015 prize with Takaaki Kajita, whose work solved the parallel atmospheric puzzle. See also discovery of oscillations.
Frequently asked questions
Why did many physicists doubt the chlorine experiment at first?
It counted only a few argon atoms per month in 615 tonnes of liquid, and the solar model had its own uncertainties, so either could plausibly have been wrong. Later independent experiments confirmed Davis' result.
Is the solar neutrino problem completely solved?
The main deficit is explained by oscillations with the MSW effect. Details, such as the predicted rise of survival probability between about 3 and 5 MeV, are still being measured.
Original papers
- TheoryJ. N. Bahcall, Solar Neutrinos. I. Theoretical, Phys. Rev. Lett. 12, 300 (1964)DOI 10.1103/PhysRevLett.12.300
- First resultR. Davis Jr., D. S. Harmer and K. C. Hoffman, Search for Neutrinos from the Sun, Phys. Rev. Lett. 20, 1205 (1968)DOI 10.1103/PhysRevLett.20.1205
- DiscoveryQ. R. Ahmad et al. (SNO Collaboration), Direct Evidence for Neutrino Flavor Transformation from Neutral-Current Interactions in the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 011301 (2002)DOI 10.1103/PhysRevLett.89.011301
Related terms
People
- Bruno Pontecorvo
- John Norris Bahcall
- Masatoshi Koshiba
- Raymond Davis Jr.
- Yoji Totsuka
- Vladimir Naumovich Gribov
- Yōichirō Suzuki
- Bruce T. Cleveland
On the timeline
- 1968Homestake finds too few solar neutrinos
- 1969Oscillations proposed to explain the solar deficit
- 1989Kamiokande sees solar neutrinos in real time
- 1998Homestake publishes its final solar result
Mentioned in 82 pages
Comparisons 1
Milestones 18
- 1939 · Stellar fusion predicts neutrinos from the Sun
- 1946 · Pontecorvo proposes the chlorine-argon detector
- 1964 · Bahcall and Davis propose a solar neutrino test
- 1968 · Homestake finds too few solar neutrinos
- 1969 · Oscillations proposed to explain the solar deficit
- 1978 · Wolfenstein: matter changes neutrino oscillations
- 1985 · Chen proposes a heavy-water solar detector
- 1985 · Mikheyev and Smirnov discover resonant conversion
10 more
- 1989 · Kamiokande sees solar neutrinos in real time
- 1992 · GALLEX observes solar pp neutrinos
- 1998 · Homestake publishes its final solar result
- 2001 · SNO shows solar neutrinos change flavour
- 2002 · KamLAND sees reactor antineutrinos disappear
- 2002 · Nobel Prize for neutrino astrophysics
- 2002 · SNO measures the total solar neutrino flux
- 2007 · Borexino measures beryllium-7 solar neutrinos in real time
- 2015 · Breakthrough Prize honours five oscillation experiments
- 2015 · Nobel Prize for neutrino oscillations
People 32
- Alexei Yuryevich Smirnov
- Arthur B. McDonald
- Atsuto Suzuki
- Bruce T. Cleveland
- Charles L. Critchfield
- Evgeny Kh. Akhmedov
- George Ewan
- Gianluigi Fogli
24 more
- Hans Bethe
- Herbert H. Chen
- John Norris Bahcall
- Kenneth Lande
- Kunio Inoue
- Lev Borisovich Okun
- Lincoln Wolfenstein
- M. Concepción (Concha) González-García
- Marc H. Pinsonneault
- Masatoshi Koshiba
- Masayuki Nakahata
- Raymond Davis Jr.
- Roger K. Ulrich
- Shoichi Sakata
- Soo-Bong Kim
- Stanislav Pavlovich Mikheyev
- Stephen J. Parke
- Stuart Jay Freedman
- Till A. Kirsten
- Vadim Alekseevich Kuzmin
- Veniamin Sergeevich Berezinsky
- Vladimir Naumovich Gribov
- Wick C. Haxton
- Yōichirō Suzuki
Terms 27
- Charged-current vs Neutral-current detection
- Chlorine–Argon method
- Discovery of neutrino oscillations
- Electron neutrino
- Experiments & detectors
- Helioseismology
- Homestake Chlorine Experiment
- KamLAND
19 more
- Large mixing angle (LMA) MSW solution
- Matter effects
- Mixing angle θ12
- MSW effect
- Neutrino capture on nuclei
- Neutrino in the Standard Model
- Neutrino magnetic moment
- Nuclear weak processes
- Radiochemical detectors
- Radiochemical signal (transmutation)
- Reactor antineutrinos
- Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF)
- SNO (Sudbury Neutrino Observatory)
- Solar neutrino experiments
- Solar neutrino unit (SNU)
- Solar neutrinos
- Spin-flavour precession
- Standard solar Model
- Underground laboratories
Last updated: · Editorial standard
Cite this page
Text
Neutrino Atlas (2026). “Solar neutrino problem”. Retrieved 22 November 2026, from https://neutrino-atlas.com/terms/solar-neutrino-problem/BibTeX
@misc{neutrinoatlas2026ermssolarneutrinoproblem,
title = {Solar neutrino problem},
author = {{Neutrino Atlas}},
year = {2026},
url = {https://neutrino-atlas.com/terms/solar-neutrino-problem/},
note = {Accessed 2026-11-22},
language = {english}
}